Always a Person, Never an Automation.

Contact Us

Insurance questions, or looking for a quote? Please provide your information, and we will contact you soon. We look forward to connecting with you.

Email: Ellen@ellenfenton.com
Call : 716 699 2044
Text: 716-309-5029

Ellen Fenton with glasses smiling at a the Ellicottville Winery, with pink roses in a vase and drinks in front of her. The background shows festive string lights and a wooden ceiling detail.

Serving our community with integrity.

  • Excellent service, and very easy to work with! I manage a small non-profit, and often need to provide various insurance documents to the State. We are happy to work with such a reliable, detail oriented, and friendly agency. Ellen is great!

    April R.

  • Effortlessly saved me money on my insurance policies

    Reed R.

  • Ellen is very professional and willing to help get the most coverage possible according to what you can afford. Great Lady

    Wendy D.

  • I have known Ellen and her sister since high school and when I purchased my new vehicle I called Ellen for help. Ellen secured the best insurance rate for me. Very professional, knowledgeable, and as always, kind. Thank you Ellen Fenton & Compan

    Monica T.

Insurance things you should know...

Insurance Talk
5 Home Insurance Questions Western New York Homeowners Should Ask
5 Home Insurance Questions Western New York Homeowners Should Ask

Homeowners insurance can become outdated as your home changes. Here are five common questions Western New York homeowners should ask about renovations, finished basements, detached structures, water damage, and changes in property use.

Read more →
Why Your New York Insurance Renewal May Look Different
Why Your New York Insurance Renewal May Look Different

Insurance renewals can change for many reasons, even when nothing obvious has changed at home. Here’s what New York customers should know and why having a local agent to call still matters.

Read more →
Your Child Is Leaving for College. Is Your Insurance Ready?
Your Child Is Leaving for College. Is Your Insurance Ready?

Sending a child to college is exciting, but it also brings important insurance questions. Learn what to review about auto insurance, renters insurance, personal belongings, and household changes before move-in day.

Read more →
Why Business Insurance Isn’t One-Size-Fits-All
Why Business Insurance Isn’t One-Size-Fits-All
Read more →
Are Your Boat, Camper, ATV, or Trailer Actually Covered This Summer?
Are Your Boat, Camper, ATV, or Trailer Actually Covered This Summer?
Read more →
Read More

Why Choose Ellen Fenton & Company?

  • Over 30 Years of Expertise – Ellen Fenton brings decades of experience and a deep understanding of the insurance industry.

  • Personalized, Local Service – With offices in Ellicottville and Franklinville, NY, we serve clients across New York and Pennsylvania.

  • Independent & Client-Focused – We work for you, not the insurance companies, ensuring you get the best coverage at the best price.

  • A Team That Cares – You’re not just a policyholder—you’re part of the EFC family.

FAQs

  • EFC provides a wide range of insurance solutions, including home, auto, renters, business, commercial, and recreational vehicle insurance across New York and Pennsylvania.

  • Homeowners and renters insurance protects your belongings from fire, theft, and other unexpected events. It also provides liability coverage in case someone is injured on your property.

  • If you need to file a claim, contact us directly, and we’ll guide you through the process to ensure a smooth and quick resolution.

  • We provide coverage for businesses of all sizes, including Business Owners Packages (BOP), commercial auto, general liability, contractor’s insurance, and restaurant & bar coverage.